A standard Northern Pacific two-story depot was also erected in 1899. This allowed the station agent and family to reside in the second story. G.H. Kelly became the first station agent and Cabril Hanson was the section boss for the McHenry district. The original depot was replaced in 1959 by a standard NP pre-fab metal station. As passenger service declined, passenger service would be provided by a gas-electric combination passenger/mail/baggage outfit nicknamed the "Galloping Goose" which ran from Valley City to Sanborn, up to McHenry and back. This was common on many North Dakota branchlines in the declining years of passenger service. This service was discontinued on June 22, 1961, and the line became freight only.
In March of 1970 the Northern Pacific, Great Northern, Chicago Burlington and Quincy, and Spokane Portland and Seattle railroads merged to become the Burlington Northern Railroad. BN continued to operate this branch until 1981, at which point the BN filed to abandon the line between Binford and McHenry. The last train ran on May 5, 1981, hauling out the 1959 depot with three GP9s and a former CB&Q caboose. See the Photo Gallery for pictures.